Mauch’s way

Preacher of fundamentals has 12th-most wins all-time

November 23, 2009

COOPERSTOWN, N.Y. – He was a champion of bunting, defense and sound fundamentals.

But his tagline remains: “The Best Manager Who Never Won a Pennant.”

Gene Mauch is one of twenty finalists for election to the Hall of Fame Class of 2010 by the Veterans Committee. (National Baseball Hall of Fame Library)

Gene Mauch, however, was much more.

“Strictly speaking, Mauch may be the best manager in baseball because he takes the players he’s given and does the most that can possibly be done with them,” said Orioles shortstop Mark Belanger – who played for future Hall of Famer manager Earl Weaver – in 1979.

Mauch, who managed the Phillies, Expos, Twins and Angels, is one of 10 finalists on this year’s Veterans Committee managers/umpires ballot at the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. The Veterans Committee will vote on Dec. 6 at baseball’s Winter Meetings in Indianapolis, and the results of the vote will be announced Dec. 7. The results of the Veterans Committee election for executives will also be announced on Dec. 7.

The 10 candidates on the managers/umpires ballot are: Charlie Grimm, Doug Harvey, Whitey Herzog, Davey Johnson, Tom Kelly, Billy Martin, Danny Murtaugh, Hank O’Day, Steve O’Neill and Mauch. Any candidate who receives at least 75 percent of all ballots cast will be enshrined in the Hall of Fame as part of the Class of 2010.

Mauch was born Nov. 18, 1925, in Salina, Kan., and grew up in Southern California. In 1943, he signed with the Brooklyn Dodgers – and Mauch made his big league debut at 18 years old the next year. He played nine big league seasons – never more than 72 games in any one season – and retired in the winter of 1958.

From there, Mauch – who had been a player-manager with the Atlanta Crackers 1953 in the Southern Association – became the boss of the Red Sox’s Triple-A affiliate in Minneapolis in 1958 and 1959. When Philadelphia manager Eddie Sawyer resigned one game into the 1960 season, the Phillies summoned Mauch.

Two years later, Mauch led the once-woeful Phils to an 81-80 record. And in 1964, Philadelphia led the National League for most of the season. On the morning of Sept. 21, the Phillies held a 6½-game advantage over the rest of the NL with just 12 games remaining. Ten days later, the Phillies had lost 10 straight games and never recovered.

Nonetheless, Mauch was voted the National League Manager of the Year by The Associated Press.

“Lose the first three holes of a golf match, and they say you weren’t warmed up,” Mauch said. “Lose the last three, and they say you choked.”

Mauch’s teams quickly became known for their “small ball” style of play. Mauch would often play for one run, advancing runners with a bunt or playing the hit-and-run. He was also an early proponent of situational substitution, once sending up seven pinch-hitters in a row in an Aug. 6, 1979, game against Seattle.

In the era before massive home run totals dominated the game, this style often turned losing teams into contending ones. But in the end, Mauch was only interested in winning.

“Platooning isn’t worth a (darn) if you don’t win the game,” Mauch said.

Mauch’s Phillies finished above .500 from 1962-67, but he was fired from the job 54 games into the 1968 season. Mauch was soon named the manager of the expansion Montreal Expos, and within five years he had the club contending for the NL East title.

Hall of Fame manager Dick Williams was a third base coach for Mauch with the Expos in 1970 between managerial jobs with the Red Sox and the A’s.

“If there was a clinic run by all the major league managers, Mauch would be the head instructor,” wrote Williams in his autobiography No More Mr. Nice Guy.

The Expos fired Mauch after the 1975 season, but he hooked on with the Twins in 1976. He managed the Twins for four full seasons and part of a fifth, finishing above .500 three times. He was fired during the 1980 season, but hired right before the 1981 strike to manage the Angels.

In 1982, Mauch led California to the AL West title. The Angels took a 2-games-to-none lead in the best-of-5 ALCS, only to see Milwaukee become the first team in LCS history to rally from a 2-0 deficit.

Mauch resigned after the 1982 season to take care of his ill wife, but returned to the club as manager in 1985 and led the Angels to a second-place finish. The next year, California again won the AL West – only to lose the ALCS to the Red Sox after leading 3-games-to-1 and 5-2 in the top of the ninth inning of Game 5.

The next season, the Angels finished last in the AL West. Mauch resigned as the Angels manager in Spring Training of 1988.

His final record: 1,902-2,037 (.483) in 26 seasons, including two first-place finishes and two second-place finishes. His victory total ranks 12th all-time, and no Hall of Fame-eligible manager has more wins than Mauch.

Mauch died on Aug. 8, 2005, at the age of 79.

Craig Muder is the director of communications for the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum




Finalists for 2010
Veterans Committee Elections

The Veterans Committee will vote on Dec. 6 at baseball’s Winter Meetings in Indianapolis, and the results of the vote will be announced Dec. 7. Two committees will vote, one on managers/umpires and a separate one for executives. All 20 finalists, including 10 executives, eight managers and two umpires are listed below:


National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum

25 Main Street, Cooperstown, NY 13326
Phone: 1-888-HALL-OF-FAME | Fax: 607-547-2044
Email the Hall of Fame

Copyright 2010 National Baseball Hall of Fame